The Rohingya Genocide: A Historic Judgment, the Crisis of International Justice, and the Search for a Secure Homeland

Ghulam M. Suhrawardi

Genocide involves the total or partial destruction of a particular group of people, on the basis of their nationality, ethnicity, race, or religion. It is as close to an anathema to all that is civilized as is conceivable. Following the Holocaust, all States undertook, in the 1948 Genocide Convention, to avoid any recurrence. However, it remains all too frequently a feature of modern warfare, and the relevant international machinery has been frustrated largely by the interests of major States.

That an ICJ judgment should find that genocide had been committed by one of its members is therefore highly significant. By 9 votes to 6, the Court held that Myanmar was liable for the genocide which in 2017 resulted in some 730,000 Rohingya fleeing to Bangladesh and about 10,000 killings. After years of persecution and deprivation, including deprivation of citizenship and land, the Rohingya thus at last received formal acknowledgment at the highest international level that these acts had been perpetrated against them, despite the failures of both military and diplomatic action.

Because The Gambia brought the case, another significant aspect of this judgment is that it confirms that all states have both an interest in, and a responsibility to act on, preventing genocide anywhere in the world. With the backing of the member States of the Organization of Islamic Cooperation, it is hard to see how any doubt could be entertained about this once a small country with no obvious stake in events in this part of the world took the initiative.

Of course, this is a fundamental tenet of much of international law. Here, a small country placed this issue before the ICJ and the rest of the world.

Bangladesh and other small and weaker countries will note with particular interest the availability of this forum, albeit subject to jurisdictional constraints, and the difficulties of securing implementation of adverse judgments. It must be valued as an important check on a purely gun-jumping world.

A History of Exclusion and Persecution

Of course, the events of August 2017 were not the starting point for the sufferings of the Rohingya. A history of discrimination and competing histories and perceptions goes back many years, all serving to marginalize and deny the legitimacy of the presence of Rohingya in what was once called Arakan and is now Rakhine State. All Governments since independence have, to varying degrees, denied that the Rohingya are truly part of Myanmar, casting them as illegal migrants.

Under the Citizenship Law introduced in 1982, many Rohingya would be denied citizenship, and over time they came to be denied a wide range of other basic rights, including free movement within their own country, and the right to work, attend school, marry freely, and receive adequate medical care.

In addition, they faced sporadic attacks by both the military and civilians. As a result of fighting in Rakhine State in 2012, more than 100,000 were displaced, mostly from their villages, increasing the separation of the two communities. The series of attacks conducted by the military throughout 2016 and into 2017 led to mass killing and exodus.

These actions by the military in 2017 were claimed to be necessary to eliminate insurgents after attacks mounted by ARSA. Clearly, the extent of killing, destruction of property, rape and other attacks on women, and the general driving of people, often whole families, from their villages and over the border was well in excess of any such aim.

Clearly, according to the ICJ, many of these acts would amount to acts of genocide, carried out with the required specific intent against a significant proportion of the Rohingya.

It goes some way towards rejecting the frequent reliance upon the need to protect one’s country from internal threats as grounds upon which to inflict widespread harm on sections of civilians.

International Justice Under Pressure

This comes at a very worrying juncture for the international legal framework. As one of the key architects of the international order since 1945, the US has grown increasingly unwilling to accept the findings of international judicial bodies when they impinge on its national security priorities.

Of course, the two Courts in question differ clearly. The ICJ is responsible for resolving inter-state conflicts; the ICC for trying natural persons for alleged genocidal acts, crimes against humanity and war crimes. But this should not preclude concern regarding the US stance towards each.

As noted above, the US explicitly recognized in 2022 that the Burmese junta was guilty of committing genocide and other crimes against the Rohingya population. It has therefore not declined to follow the ICJ’s decision in that case. But taken together with the rest of the current US Administration’s opposition to international legal recourse, the implications for US adherence to these frameworks are worrying.

US Secretary of State Rubio’s comments last week calling into question the primacy of the ICC relative to ‘the sword’ are similarly alarming. While focused specifically on the ICC, this type of comment will have equally detrimental effects on perceptions of the legitimacy of any Court.

Naturally, we should not say that the US has set out to dismantle the ICJ. But as successive administrations seek to undermine, threaten, and fail to comply with the rulings of such Courts, the integrity of the global judicial system will inevitably suffer.

This is especially problematic given the US’ historic contribution to setting up an international system designed to ensure the horrors of the Second World War were never repeated. By resisting the judgments of such Courts, the US sets a dangerous example to other major world powers.

Ultimately, international law will carry weight only to the extent it is applied regardless of the provenance of those being prosecuted.

China and India: Strategic Interests Above Human Rights

The approach taken by China and India to the Rohingya situation highlights a further shortcoming of current international relations. Each nation wields considerable leverage in Myanmar, but to date this has not been deployed to ensure any real degree of safeguarding for the Rohingya.

This is driven largely by China’s extensive economic footprint in Myanmar, including the CMEC, Kyaukphyu Port and a network of oil and gas pipelines running from the Bay of Bengal to South-West China. Through these assets, China can gain greater direct access to the Indian Ocean and reduce its reliance on potentially hostile sea lanes.

Similarly, India has significant commercial and national security interests in Myanmar (e.g., the Kaladan project; road and rail links to its NE States; securing its eastern frontier; countering Chinese incursion). But India’s response to the plight of the Rohingya betrays a stark dissonance with its professed values as a liberal democracy. Far from offering safe harbor to Rohingya who seek refuge from persecution in Myanmar, it has repeatedly sought to deport them as ‘illegal migrants’, often through coercive measures. This is all the more problematic given the Rohingya are overwhelmingly Muslim and that India is currently led by a right-wing Hindu party.

In May 2025, 100 Rohingya were reported to have been driven back across the frontier into Bangladesh. More shockingly, some 40 Rohingya, amongst them females and minors, were placed on an Indian Navy ship and pushed out to sea off Myanmar, before wading onto the shore. The UN Human Rights Office and other aid agencies have expressed concern at these developments. HRW has confirmed that no fewer than 192 Rohingya, some bearing UN registration, were returned to Bangladesh. In doing so, India appears to be flouting the tenet of non-refoulement. As well as failing the Rohingya, India thereby shifts the responsibility of hosting this displaced community onto its neighbor Bangladesh, which already cares for an extremely large number of Rohingya.

Nor does China or India’s interest in the region preclude them from taking steps to halt the ongoing atrocities against the Rohingya. As two of Asia’s largest economies and militaries, they will want to show they can champion key Western-led norms if they hope to assume a more prominent role on the world stage.

Each State will have justifiable reasons to seek to contain conflict and insurgencies within Myanmar. But allowing the Rohingya to continue suffering under these circumstances will only exacerbate those risks in the longer term. How can a stateless mass of people living in squalor form the bedrock of a stable and harmonious Southeast Asia?

It is therefore imperative that China and India look to uphold the rights of the Rohingya in pursuit of their own strategic aims.

Bangladesh and the Burden of Displacement

Bangladesh has borne the brunt of Myanmar’s Rohingya crisis. Around 1.2m Rohingya currently live in Bangladesh, mainly in camps in the Cox’s Bazar region. This situation has created significant strain on Bangladeshi resources, including state provision, forests, roads, jobs, and social harmony.

Bangladesh deserves credit for this continued hospitality. However, charity will only go so far.

There are clear dangers facing the Rohingya, from poor education to reduced aid and an increasing infiltration of illicit actors. Children will grow up with little chance of becoming citizens, working or having a home.

By confirming Myanmar’s culpability for the events that led to the Rohingya flight, the ICJ decision affords Bangladesh greater leverage in negotiations. Furthermore, it reiterates the need for the return of Rohingya to Myanmar to be free, safe, and secure, with binding commitments.

Nonetheless, the Court cannot force Myanmar to take back its displaced nationals. Any steps needed to achieve this can be considered by the UN Security Council, although the international community’s inability to reach consensus on such matters is well known.

It is a notable failing of our current system of international law.

The Case for an Autonomous Rohingya Homeland

This decision should form the basis for further political progress. Resettling all returnees under systems of administration similar to those that previously existed, and thus subjecting them to similar discrimination, would set the stage for further disasters.

At minimum, there should be serious consideration given to providing a viable area of autonomy to the Rohingya somewhere inside present-day Myanmar.

This is not necessarily advocating a separate State. Sizeable areas of northern Rakhine State, with appropriate constitutional safeguards and concessions agreed following discussions with Rohingya and others, might allow an appropriate degree of citizenship, self-governance, political participation, preservation of language and customs, and economic growth.

Of course, this should not be at the expense of the legitimate settlement and property of Buddhists and others, who would also be expected to enjoy all rights of citizens. So, this should be achieved by political means and agreement of all groups concerned, rather than simple partition.

The question is further complicated by the takeover of large areas of Rakhine State by various rebel groups, in particular the Arakan Army. The latter at least professes to want a degree of self-governance for all races in the area, but there are many allegations of mistreatment of Rohingya, which, if true, are troubling.

Clearly, it would be no advance if the current military regime were simply replaced by further military rule over the Rohingya and denial of basic rights.

There would need to be substantial provisions, probably with an international element, on all aspects of security; restoration of citizenship; security of land and other property tenure; movement; education and work opportunities; conflict arbitration; and so on.

Substantial foreign funding could go toward rebuilding roads and other infrastructure and supporting agricultural, fishing, and other enterprises. All these could help develop a reasonably self-sufficient economic area in northern Rakhine.

All this is widely recognized as very problematic. But continuing large-scale exile and periodic outbreaks of violence is surely immoral, and also impractical in the longer term.

The Future of International Justice

The impact of this case could therefore extend well beyond Asia. A number of situations, including Ukraine and Gaza, are currently being argued under the Genocide Convention.

This is significant precedent that the ICJ will be ready to attribute acts of genocide to States. Of course, its decisions are only effective to the extent that States choose to comply.

Clearly, many aspects of the judgment will face scrutiny, as is to be expected. But seeking to diminish and undermine the role of the international courts simply because they may give inconvenient answers to powerful countries would be very damaging.

There will always be scope to challenge various elements of any court’s reasoning. That should not extend to intimidating or seeking to deprive international courts of their functions.

Of course, it is particularly important for small and weaker States to have recourse to such bodies. Otherwise, they could find themselves at the mercy of others’ finances, politics, and armed forces.

Clearly, a country of the size of The Gambia can play an important part in advancing international law. Many others should follow its example in standing firm in support of these international bodies.

Obviously, great attention will now turn to compliance with the judgment. Reparations and restitution, prosecutions, and an environment in which Rohingya could return are all necessary. International help and oversight would play an obvious role in all respects, as would continued pressure from Bangladesh, ASEAN, China and India, and indeed all UN Member States.

Above all, the Rohingya would need an effective say in how they wished to be governed in future. It is hard to see how any agreement between governments, generals and other countries would be satisfactory.

It is remarkable that the Court reached this conclusion on 19 November 2016. Much remains to be done to ensure security for the Rohingya.

The key test will simply be if large numbers of Rohingya are able to go back to their homes, reclaim land and assets, become citizens and send their children to school free from harassment.

A secure and constitutionally guaranteed autonomous homeland within a restructured Myanmar deserves serious international consideration as part of that future.

The world has now formally acknowledged the genocide committed against the Rohingya. The responsibility that follows is unmistakable: recognition must become restitution, justice must become security, and displacement must finally give way to a durable homeland.

A civilization that can identify genocide but cannot protect its survivors has fulfilled only half its moral obligation.



author

Ghulam M. Suhrawardi

Ghulam M. Suhrawardi is the Publisher of South Asia Journal.

Source: https://southasiajournal.net/post/bangladesh/61962/the-rohingya-genocide-a-historic-judgment-the-crisis-of-international-justice-and-the-search-for-a-secure-homeland

LEAVE A REPLY

Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here