Sonia Gandhi: Belonging – Love-Journey & Politics!

Nilofar Suhrawardy

Sonia Gandhi’s decision to come out with a book at this stage, when informally she still remains in command of Congress to a considerable extent, apparently carries a certain message. The title of the book- “Belonging, A Journey of Love” – in itself bears its own significance. The title could just have been just- “A Journey of Love.” The book would still have been received as well it is being now. The response at present is being more strongly decided by the name of the author than by the title that has been written. “Belonging” – this word has perhaps been inserted specifically to draw attention to Sonia in this stage, to her sense of belonging at various levels. It cannot be ignored that India has been witness to phases when deliberate attention appears to have been paid to treat her as an outsider, view her as a foreigner, who couldn’t be perhaps always accepted in the fold of Indian politics and so forth. Time and again, Sonia probably has had to face an invisible wall, which perhaps has never seemed to exist. It is possible, the title suggests effort which has been put in by her to cross the wall to prove her sense of Belonging. Yet the wall has existed, if not for her, perhaps for some others. If nothing else, she is apparently trying to do so again, display her sense of belonging, by giving importance to her marriage with Rajiv Gandhi, her acceptance by Indira Gandhi, her command of Congress and more. Well, one can draw numerous interpretations from each and every issue she has chosen to elaborate on in her book.
Perhaps, this also explains Sonia having attempted to give emphasis to her personal relations, within her immediate family, from the one she was born into to the one she was married into. She was born in a village in Italy. She has apparently laid stress on her marital ties with the family she “belonged” to and was accepted into. The message of her actually “belonging” here appears to have been writ large by her. In essence, she has been doing so for greater part of life as Sonia Gandhi, as Rajiv’s wife, Congress leader, as one married into a Hindu family, as a parliamentarian and more.
It is not possible for Sonia Gandhi to have documented each and every important part of her life spread over 79 years into one book. In all probability, what she has managed to, has taken a lot of time. Whether this is linked to her family life, the extremely critical moments, when Indira Gandhi was assassinated, when Rajiv Gandhi was killed, her entry into politics, that of children and so on; she has probably been through a tough phase deliberating on a lot, what to include and what not. to However many times one relives certain memories, just as one can never laugh enough while recalling some, there are others for which tears can stop never filling eyes again and again. It is not an easy task living such a life just once, when almost every minute seems a practical test of the dilemma one is facing. This is simply because practically each and every moment of one’s life, one remains in the eye of public, politicians, supporters as well as opponents, family members, security and more.
Though initially she and Rajiv desired to remain apolitical, their destiny decided otherwise. And both were literally pushed into it at different periods. But once inside politics, the question of abandoning ceased to prevail. The book cannot be expected to be without tones, intricacies, complexities, nuances and more of Sonia the politician not simply trying to have her say but probably also hoping to assert it.  She has done so as a Congress leader in her references to Maneka Gandhi, Narsimha Rao, Pranab Mukherjee and others. It was perhaps important for her to do so as a public figure, whose political identity was partly based due to the family she was wedded into and partly how she carved her own place in her party and the Indian political scenario. In the latter context, in political life, it may be noted she has not refrained from using various religious symbols as and when which is deemed appropriate.
Sonia seems to have chosen the book as a medium to have her say on a few fronts whether directly, indirectly, candidly or as it may be interpreted. She has asserted this probably as her right to do so, as one who has finally chosen to express so now after years of deliberating and remaining largely quiet on the same. She is not one of those politicians whose views are frequently and periodically aired. Of course, they are when she chooses to speak, but doing so hasn’t seemed to be her second nature even when she has been more actively engaged in politics.
However much is said in favor or criticism of Sonia’s memoirs, just a few hundred words cannot be expected to do justice to it. Certainly, she has taken several steps forward by coming out with this book- as Rajiv’s wife, a member of Gandhi family, as a politician and apparently more so. It is also apparently her seeking to express a sense of belonging at these levels as well as her own self. It wouldn’t be perhaps wrong to say that she has come a long way at these levels to cross several walls.
Given the title of the book and that it is based on Sonia’s memoirs, her view, attitude, reflections on what she has been attached to, affected by, interested in or not interested in and so forth, it may be best to view the same as such only. Her memoirs are based on her views and may best not be viewed as a part of any research-oriented work.
It is possible, earlier, throughout the course of her engagement in politics, she has not always been able to assert her stand openly. She says towards the end, “…although I tried my best, I didn’t succeed in beating back the forces I’d set out to fight.” Unhesitatingly, she acknowledges having encountered “overwhelming joy and lacerating sorrow,” “honesty and deceit” and “kindness and cruelty.” Notwithstanding the “traumas and difficulties” she faced, Sonia acknowledges being “sustained” by love from her husband and family as well as people of the country. In essence, her memoirs are her memoirs and not any research-oriented work demanding research-oriented analysis. This is what this book should probably be viewed as, her approach towards her life and as mentioned not any detailed research/analysis. That she has finally managed to comment now on her life and sense of belonging has perhaps its own reasons, spelling perhaps her satisfaction in doing so at this stage of her life, when perhaps she can afford to!


author

Nilofar Suhrawardy

Nilofar Suhrawardy is a Senior Journalist. She has come out with four books: Modi’s Victory, A Lesson for the Congress (2019), Arab Spring, Not Just a Mirage (2019), Image and Substance: Modi’s First Year in Office (2015) and Ayodhya Without Communal Stamp: In the Name of Indian Secularism (2006).

Source: https://southasiajournal.net/post/india/61952/sonia-gandhi-belonging-love-journey-politics

LEAVE A REPLY

Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here