Executive becomes arrogant, uncontrolled: SC

The Appellate Division of the Supreme Court has observed that human rights are at stake, corruption is rampant and Parliament is dysfunctional.

The apex court made the observation in its full text of the verdict on Constitution’s 16th Amendment released on Tuesday in which Parliament’s power to remove Supreme Court judges was declared illegal.

The apex court also said that crores of people are deprived of basic health care, crimes are increasing, acute mismanagement in the administration, the life and security utterly becomes unsecured and the law enforcing agencies are unable to tackle the situation.

The court said that the combined  result  of  all  this, is  a crippled  society,  a  society  where  good  man  does  not dream of good things at all; but the bad man is all the  more restless  to  grab  a  few  more  of  bounty.

‘In such a situation, the Executive becomes arrogant and uncontrolled and the bureaucracy will never opt for efficiency,’ the court said.

The court said, ‘Instead of strengthening the judiciary, the Executive is now trying to cripple it and if it happens, there could be disastrous consequences.’

The court said, ‘Even  after  forty-six  years  of  independence,  we have  not  been  able  to  institutionalise  any  public institutions.

‘There are no checks and balances, there  is no watchdog mechanism at work, thus the people in the  position  are  being  indulged  into  abuse  of  power and  showing  audacity  of  freehand  exercise  of  power,’ the court said.

It said, ‘The state power, which is another dimension  of political power, is becoming a monopoly of a few now-a-days and this suicidal tendency of concentration of power  is  increasing.’

The court said that the  greed  for  power  is  a  like plague,  once  set  in  motion  it  will  try  to  devour everything.

‘Needless to say, this was not at all the aims and vision of our liberation struggle.  Our Forefathers fought to establish a democratic state, not to produce any power-monster,’ the court said.

The court said that after  independence,  those  unholy  alliances  of power-mongers twice reduced the country to a banana  Republic,  where  people  were seen  as  commodity  which can  be  bluffed  and  compromised  at  any  unworthy  cost to  legalise  their  illegitimate  exercise  of  power.

‘Politics is no longer free, it is now  highly  commercial  and  money  is  in  the  driving seat  which  controls  the  course  of  action  and  its destination,’ the court said.

The court said that now power, not merit, tends to control all public institutions of the country.

The court said, ‘Irony of the history  is  that  with  the  unflinching determination and  indomitable  spirit,  we  were  able  to  free  a country  from  the  clutches  of  a  military  superpower but we have been measurably defeated by ourselves in that very free country’.

The court said that before  assuming  the  powers  the  members  of Parliament should have considered as to whether they are  capable  of  dealing  with  such  responsibility.

‘This is what we call ‘institutional virtuosity’ by itself is not enough without ‘individual virtuosity’ and we have to strive for that if we really want to build the Bangabandhu’s dream of ‘Sonar Bangla’,’ the court said.

Source: New Age